冒雨 脫隊 連犯登山大忌 搏命救難... - 健行
By Andrew
at 2011-11-12T16:01
at 2011-11-12T16:01
Table of Contents
冒雨 脫隊 連犯登山大忌 搏命救難 應尊重專業判斷
2011-11-12 中國時報 【廖肇祥/特稿】
政治鬥爭時,扣帽子是常見的手法,但在山難救援上,請收回廉價的帽子,並留給
救難人員確保安全的空間。任何一條人命都無價,無論成敗,救難人員都是英雄,社會看
待山難救援,請收拾激情,留給專業。
民國八十九年七月廿二日,八名為第五河川局做固床工的工人因山洪突然爆發,受
困在暴漲的溪水,其中四人因收拾工具來不及走避,抱在八掌溪中等待救援,但因各機關
本位主義,加以器材不足,四名工人在SNG車轉播下被溪水沖走。
「八掌溪事件」與康吉成山難,兩起事件其實不能等量齊觀,尤其是山洪爆發難以
預知,四名工人困在溪水中命懸一線,且因而殉難。
反觀康吉成是登山遊憩,輕忽中央氣象局豪大雨特報上山在先,又與嚮導脫隊,犯
了獨攀的大忌,難道康本人與讓伙伴落單的嚮導毫無責任?
山難救援不是坐在電視機前的觀眾想像中那樣簡單,山谷中風向不定,突然間來一
陣大霧,看不見五公尺外的伙伴;何況南湖大山五岩峰往中央尖山的斷崖與落石,是出了
名的危險;因此山區救難不是在玩電玩「越南大戰」,救難人員緊急著裝,日夜跋涉趕抵
現場、直升機冒著視線不良出勤,這都是在搏命。
已故的美籍山區搜救協會教官狄克(Dick Sale),是國內山難救援現代化的啟蒙
者,他給受訓學員的叮嚀是「第一先自保、第二自保、第三還是自保」,但國內救援任務
執行當中,「激情」常凌駕「專業判斷」,在「莫讓八掌溪事件重演」的上綱下,要求救
難人員「勉強」出勤,我們難以確知,有多少救難人員是在社會氛圍逼迫下殉職,但很確
定在逼迫的氛圍下,殉職的機率大增。
盼望家屬及民代留給救難人員專業的空間,並提供充足的資源,無論成敗,都要給
予肯定,畢竟,搏命的是他們,誰無父母?
--------------------
我覺得這篇文章,寫的真好
沒錯,誰無父母、誰無妻小...
請不要一昧的怪救難專業人員....
請不要認為救到幾個人,就可以把期望放在他身上
與其這麼會怪政府,到不如出來選立委、選總統
別忘了你的家人,耗費多大的社會資源
救援中,一直怪東怪西
救援後,有道歉過嗎?
我只是個穿梭山林的小小山友而已...
--
2011-11-12 中國時報 【廖肇祥/特稿】
政治鬥爭時,扣帽子是常見的手法,但在山難救援上,請收回廉價的帽子,並留給
救難人員確保安全的空間。任何一條人命都無價,無論成敗,救難人員都是英雄,社會看
待山難救援,請收拾激情,留給專業。
民國八十九年七月廿二日,八名為第五河川局做固床工的工人因山洪突然爆發,受
困在暴漲的溪水,其中四人因收拾工具來不及走避,抱在八掌溪中等待救援,但因各機關
本位主義,加以器材不足,四名工人在SNG車轉播下被溪水沖走。
「八掌溪事件」與康吉成山難,兩起事件其實不能等量齊觀,尤其是山洪爆發難以
預知,四名工人困在溪水中命懸一線,且因而殉難。
反觀康吉成是登山遊憩,輕忽中央氣象局豪大雨特報上山在先,又與嚮導脫隊,犯
了獨攀的大忌,難道康本人與讓伙伴落單的嚮導毫無責任?
山難救援不是坐在電視機前的觀眾想像中那樣簡單,山谷中風向不定,突然間來一
陣大霧,看不見五公尺外的伙伴;何況南湖大山五岩峰往中央尖山的斷崖與落石,是出了
名的危險;因此山區救難不是在玩電玩「越南大戰」,救難人員緊急著裝,日夜跋涉趕抵
現場、直升機冒著視線不良出勤,這都是在搏命。
已故的美籍山區搜救協會教官狄克(Dick Sale),是國內山難救援現代化的啟蒙
者,他給受訓學員的叮嚀是「第一先自保、第二自保、第三還是自保」,但國內救援任務
執行當中,「激情」常凌駕「專業判斷」,在「莫讓八掌溪事件重演」的上綱下,要求救
難人員「勉強」出勤,我們難以確知,有多少救難人員是在社會氛圍逼迫下殉職,但很確
定在逼迫的氛圍下,殉職的機率大增。
盼望家屬及民代留給救難人員專業的空間,並提供充足的資源,無論成敗,都要給
予肯定,畢竟,搏命的是他們,誰無父母?
--------------------
我覺得這篇文章,寫的真好
沒錯,誰無父母、誰無妻小...
請不要一昧的怪救難專業人員....
請不要認為救到幾個人,就可以把期望放在他身上
與其這麼會怪政府,到不如出來選立委、選總統
別忘了你的家人,耗費多大的社會資源
救援中,一直怪東怪西
救援後,有道歉過嗎?
我只是個穿梭山林的小小山友而已...
--
Tags:
健行
All Comments
By Megan
at 2011-11-12T23:12
at 2011-11-12T23:12
By Agatha
at 2011-11-13T21:09
at 2011-11-13T21:09
By Olive
at 2011-11-16T04:22
at 2011-11-16T04:22
By Hedda
at 2011-11-18T09:19
at 2011-11-18T09:19
By Lily
at 2011-11-23T03:37
at 2011-11-23T03:37
By Adele
at 2011-11-26T13:18
at 2011-11-26T13:18
By Mary
at 2011-11-28T13:49
at 2011-11-28T13:49
By Quintina
at 2011-11-29T02:01
at 2011-11-29T02:01
By Tristan Cohan
at 2011-12-01T20:47
at 2011-12-01T20:47
By Cara
at 2011-12-02T08:48
at 2011-12-02T08:48
By Linda
at 2011-12-04T13:07
at 2011-12-04T13:07
By Kumar
at 2011-12-07T23:51
at 2011-12-07T23:51
By Vanessa
at 2011-12-12T00:44
at 2011-12-12T00:44
By Mia
at 2011-12-15T21:32
at 2011-12-15T21:32
By Frederica
at 2011-12-17T20:06
at 2011-12-17T20:06
By Dorothy
at 2011-12-20T17:55
at 2011-12-20T17:55
By Necoo
at 2011-12-24T06:11
at 2011-12-24T06:11
By Freda
at 2011-12-28T18:13
at 2011-12-28T18:13
By Hazel
at 2012-01-01T09:55
at 2012-01-01T09:55
By Brianna
at 2012-01-03T00:32
at 2012-01-03T00:32
By Rebecca
at 2012-01-04T15:05
at 2012-01-04T15:05
By Zanna
at 2012-01-06T02:09
at 2012-01-06T02:09
By Odelette
at 2012-01-09T18:34
at 2012-01-09T18:34
By Olive
at 2012-01-11T01:39
at 2012-01-11T01:39
By Lauren
at 2012-01-13T21:57
at 2012-01-13T21:57
By Rae
at 2012-01-18T15:38
at 2012-01-18T15:38
By Caroline
at 2012-01-21T11:47
at 2012-01-21T11:47
By Heather
at 2012-01-26T00:22
at 2012-01-26T00:22
By Jacky
at 2012-01-30T22:05
at 2012-01-30T22:05
By Hedwig
at 2012-02-03T09:17
at 2012-02-03T09:17
By Jacky
at 2012-02-04T14:05
at 2012-02-04T14:05
By Frederica
at 2012-02-08T07:40
at 2012-02-08T07:40
By Hamiltion
at 2012-02-12T13:31
at 2012-02-12T13:31
By Isabella
at 2012-02-14T12:18
at 2012-02-14T12:18
By Emily
at 2012-02-19T00:49
at 2012-02-19T00:49
By Olive
at 2012-02-20T19:38
at 2012-02-20T19:38
By Agatha
at 2012-02-21T14:41
at 2012-02-21T14:41
By Agatha
at 2012-02-25T00:10
at 2012-02-25T00:10
By Hedy
at 2012-02-29T10:37
at 2012-02-29T10:37
By John
at 2012-03-04T21:40
at 2012-03-04T21:40
By Zanna
at 2012-03-06T09:50
at 2012-03-06T09:50
By Liam
at 2012-03-06T12:52
at 2012-03-06T12:52
By Hedda
at 2012-03-07T06:21
at 2012-03-07T06:21
By Steve
at 2012-03-10T15:08
at 2012-03-10T15:08
By Audriana
at 2012-03-14T01:02
at 2012-03-14T01:02
By Kelly
at 2012-03-15T04:51
at 2012-03-15T04:51
By Elvira
at 2012-03-17T05:06
at 2012-03-17T05:06
By Dinah
at 2012-03-19T03:08
at 2012-03-19T03:08
By Audriana
at 2012-03-23T15:05
at 2012-03-23T15:05
By Lydia
at 2012-03-27T17:55
at 2012-03-27T17:55
By Valerie
at 2012-03-28T01:27
at 2012-03-28T01:27
By Kyle
at 2012-03-31T13:30
at 2012-03-31T13:30
By Eden
at 2012-04-03T08:54
at 2012-04-03T08:54
By Lydia
at 2012-04-04T13:45
at 2012-04-04T13:45
By Quanna
at 2012-04-07T18:04
at 2012-04-07T18:04
By Robert
at 2012-04-07T22:00
at 2012-04-07T22:00
By Tracy
at 2012-04-12T01:41
at 2012-04-12T01:41
By Thomas
at 2012-04-15T19:02
at 2012-04-15T19:02
By Yedda
at 2012-04-16T08:17
at 2012-04-16T08:17
By Andy
at 2012-04-18T14:18
at 2012-04-18T14:18
By Mia
at 2012-04-18T16:58
at 2012-04-18T16:58
By Edward Lewis
at 2012-04-20T02:33
at 2012-04-20T02:33
By Zenobia
at 2012-04-21T08:38
at 2012-04-21T08:38
By Erin
at 2012-04-24T05:48
at 2012-04-24T05:48
By Ina
at 2012-04-25T15:08
at 2012-04-25T15:08
By Vanessa
at 2012-04-29T14:43
at 2012-04-29T14:43
By Eartha
at 2012-04-30T14:43
at 2012-04-30T14:43
By Sierra Rose
at 2012-05-04T11:40
at 2012-05-04T11:40
By Carolina Franco
at 2012-05-09T08:53
at 2012-05-09T08:53
By Zanna
at 2012-05-14T00:17
at 2012-05-14T00:17
By Faithe
at 2012-05-18T07:06
at 2012-05-18T07:06
By Liam
at 2012-05-18T13:06
at 2012-05-18T13:06
By Sierra Rose
at 2012-05-21T00:19
at 2012-05-21T00:19
By Cara
at 2012-05-22T17:16
at 2012-05-22T17:16
By Joe
at 2012-05-23T16:21
at 2012-05-23T16:21
By Kama
at 2012-05-25T08:48
at 2012-05-25T08:48
Related Posts
玉山沒擠入世界7大奇景
By Zanna
at 2011-11-12T10:43
at 2011-11-12T10:43
泰崗溫泉探路
By Ivy
at 2011-11-11T21:50
at 2011-11-11T21:50
浸水營古道路況??
By Todd Johnson
at 2011-11-11T17:35
at 2011-11-11T17:35
島嶼的屋脊 台灣登山百年紀行
By Charlie
at 2011-11-11T16:46
at 2011-11-11T16:46
玉山連峰
By Susan
at 2011-11-11T16:07
at 2011-11-11T16:07